Mid-range machines
Nokta Simplex Ultra vs Garrett ACE 400: Waterproofing vs the American Standard
Quick answer
Buy Nokta Simplex Ultra at $299.00 for a published 16 foot waterproof rating and a lower price. Buy the Garrett ACE 400 at $357.99 if you specifically want a USA-made machine with iron audio and adjustable frequency, and can live with Garrett not publishing a waterproof rating, coil size or weight for this model in our catalog.
Nokta Simplex Ultra
$299.00Fully waterproof to 16 feet, carbon fibre shaft, 2.6 lb, firmware updates over USB.
Best for: wading, surf and wet ground on a mid budget
Check price on Amazon
Garrett ACE 400
$357.99Made in the USA, digital target ID (0 to 99), iron audio, adjustable frequency, electronic pinpointing.
Best for: park and field hunting on a mid budget
Check price on AmazonThe Simplex Ultra publishes more about itself than the ACE 400 does. Nokta states a 16 foot waterproof rating, a carbon fibre shaft that retracts to 25 inches and a 2.6 lb weight for Nokta Simplex Ultra, and sells it for $299.00. Garrett's listing for Garrett ACE 400, at $357.99, documents a 0 to 99 digital target ID scale, an iron audio feature, non-motion all-metal pinpointing and adjustable frequency to fight interference, but states nothing about waterproofing, coil size or weight beyond noting it is made in the USA.
That is not a knock on the ACE 400's performance, it is a note about what this listing does and does not tell you before you buy. If a specific, published waterproof figure matters to your buying decision, the Simplex Ultra is the only one of these two that gives you one. If USA manufacturing and a long history of forum-tested settings matter more, the ACE 400 has that on its side even where the spec sheet stays quiet. The ACE 400 target ID chart and Simplex Ultra target ID chart are where to check either machine's numbers against your own ground.
Top pick
Nokta Simplex Ultra
A published 16 foot waterproof rating, a lighter 2.6 lb build and a lower price, all documented in one listing.
Price was accurate when this page was compiled and changes often.
On this page
Why is one listing so much thinner than the other?
Garrett's ACE 400 marketing leans on features that reduce false signals and dig time, iron audio and adjustable frequency chief among them, rather than on physical specs. Nokta's Simplex Ultra marketing leans the opposite way, leading with build and waterproofing. Neither approach is dishonest, but it means a side-by-side spec table has real holes on the Garrett side, and you should not assume the ACE 400 lacks a waterproof coil just because this listing does not say so. Garrett's other ACE-family machines mention waterproof searchcoils explicitly; the ACE 400 listing in our catalog does not repeat that claim for this specific model.
How do the published specifications compare?
What follows is only what each brand states in this listing.
The Simplex Ultra listing documents waterproofing, shaft material and weight that the ACE 400 listing does not state, while the ACE 400 documents iron audio and adjustable frequency the Simplex listing does not mention.
| Model | Price | Stock coil | Made in | Material |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nokta Simplex Ultra | $299.00 | 11 in | - | Carbon fibre shaft |
| Garrett ACE 400 | $357.99 | - | USA | - |
Figures are taken from each manufacturer's own published listing and specification sheet. A dash means the maker does not publish that figure for that model, not that the feature is absent.
Where does the ACE 400 listing go quiet?
Nokta documents three physical specs Garrett leaves blank for the ACE 400, and Garrett documents two discrimination features Nokta does not mention.
| Specification | Nokta Simplex Ultra | Garrett ACE 400 |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $299.00 | $357.99 |
| Waterproof rating | 16 ft (5 m) | Not published in this listing |
| Coil size | 11 in | Not published in this listing |
| Weight | 2.6 lb | Not published in this listing |
| Target ID scale | Not published in this listing | 0 to 99 digital |
| Iron audio | Not published in this listing | Yes |
| Adjustable frequency | Not published in this listing | Yes |
| Made in | Not published in this listing | USA |
| Firmware updates | Over USB from a PC | Not published in this listing |
Drawn from the Nokta Simplex Ultra and Garrett ACE 400 listings in our catalog. Several rows are genuine gaps in the marketing copy for each machine rather than evidence of a missing feature.
Choose the Simplex Ultra if
You want a documented waterproof rating before you commit, or your sites include wading and wet sand. At $299.00 it also costs less than the ACE 400 while publishing more about itself. The full Simplex Ultra review and Simplex Ultra settings by site type are the next two pages, and Simplex Ultra vs Double Score covers the step up within Nokta's own line.
Choose the ACE 400 if
USA manufacturing matters to your purchase, or you specifically want iron audio and adjustable frequency documented in the listing rather than inferred. Decades of ACE-family use also mean a deep well of published settings advice. The full ACE 400 review and ACE 400 settings by site type are worth reading before your first hunt, and ACE 300 vs ACE 400 is useful if you are deciding within the ACE line itself.
What to buy alongside either one
A pinpointer before a second coil. Garrett Pro-Pointer AT works with either machine and the how to use a pinpointer guide explains the recovery-time math. From there, run the dig time calculator against your own typical site to see how much of your afternoon is actually spent swinging versus digging, which usually reorders the next purchase on its own.
Whichever machine you buy, spend a little on carry gear before you spend anything on a second coil. CKG Finds and Digger Pouch keeps recovered targets off your belt loop and out of your pocket, and a basic pair of NoCry Professional Gel Knee Pads pays for itself the first time a dig takes longer than expected on hard ground. Neither line item changes what either detector finds, but both change how many hours you are willing to put in on a given afternoon, which over a season matters more than any single spec on this page.
Sources
- Nokta Simplex Ultra product listing and specifications
- Garrett ACE 400 product listing and specifications
Frequently asked questions
Is the Garrett ACE 400 waterproof?
Not published in this listing. Other ACE-family machines in our catalog mention a waterproof searchcoil explicitly, but the ACE 400 listing does not repeat that claim, and does not state a control housing rating either way. Check the current Garrett manual before taking it into water, and never assume a coil rating extends to the control box.
Which of these is better for a beginner?
Both suit a beginner, and the honest tiebreaker is where you hunt. If wet ground, rain or shallow water are part of your plan, the Simplex Ultra's published 16 foot rating is the safer documented choice. If you want iron audio to learn discrimination by ear and prefer a USA-made machine, the ACE 400 has decades of community settings behind it.
Does the ACE 400 have a numeric target ID?
Yes. Garrett publishes a 0 to 99 digital target ID scale for the ACE 400, the same style of scale used across most modern machines in this catalog. The exact number a given object reads at is still conditional on soil, depth and orientation, so treat the scale as an ordering to learn on your own ground rather than a fixed lookup table.
Can I add a bigger or smaller coil to the ACE 400?
Our coils catalog does not currently list an aftermarket coil specifically fitted to the ACE 400, unlike the AT series and ACE Apex, which both have documented aftermarket options. Check Garrett's current accessory list before assuming a coil swap is available, since this is a gap in what we can verify rather than a confirmed no.
Researched, not professional advice. This page is compiled from published specifications, manuals and owner-review consensus, not hands-on testing. Target ID numbers, depth figures and settings vary with soil chemistry, moisture, target size, depth, orientation and firmware version, so treat every figure here as a starting point and verify it against your own machine's manual and your own ground. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.